Religious Diversity, Interreligious Perspectives, and Islamic Religious Education in Switzerland: Current Situation and Room for Maneuver
Twenty years ago, the first pilot projects of Islamic religious education (IRE) in public schools in Switzerland caused a stir in some parts of the country. From a pedagogical perspective, the rationale for IRE, analogous to confessional Christian education, was undisputed, as it was about guiding children and young people in German in their first steps towards forming their own capacity for religious language. However, today there are only a handful of IRE projects, all of which are also located in German-speaking Switzerland. At the same time, specialized circles in Switzerland and other European countries were debating what form of religious education could be most appropriate for children and young people today. Does confessional teaching in schools (still) make sense? And if so, what should be the role of religious communities in this context? And how should religion be dealt with in other school subjects? The debates around confessional IRE as well as around “neutral” teaching about religions, potentially covering any religion, are set in the context of the megatrends of secularization, individualization, and pluralization, but also of sometimes emotionally charged societal debates around Muslim women and men as the largest religious minority.
Il y a vingt ans, les premiers projets pilotes d’enseignement religieux islamique (ERI) à l’école publique en Suisse ont fait grand bruit en certains endroits du pays. Sur le plan pédagogique, la raison d’être d’un ERI, de manière analogue à l’enseignement chrétien confessionnel, était incontestée, puisqu’il s’agissait de guider en langue allemande enfants et jeunes dans leurs premiers pas vers la formation d’une capacité de langage religieux propre. On ne compte pourtant aujourd’hui qu’une poignée de projets d’ERI, tous implantés, de surcroît, en Suisse alémanique.
À la même période, les milieux spécialisés en Suisse comme dans d’autres pays européens débattaient pour déterminer quelle forme d’éducation religieuse pouvait être la plus adaptée aux enfants et aux jeunes aujourd’hui. L’enseignement confessionnel à l’école a-t-il au juste (encore) un sens ? Et si oui, quel doit être le rôle des communautés religieuses dans ce contexte ? Et comment la religion doit-elle être traitée dans d’autres disciplines scolaires ? Les débats autour de l’ERI confessionnel comme autour d’un enseignement “neutre” sur les religions, portant potentiellement sur n’importe quelle religion, s’inscrivent dans le contexte des mégatendances que sont la sécularisation, l’individualisation et la pluralisation, mais aussi de débats de société, parfois à forte teneur émotionnelle, autour des musulmanes et musulmans en tant que plus grande minorité religieuse.
قبل عشرين عامًا، أثارت المشاريع التجريبية الأولى لتعليم الدين الإسلامي في المدارس العامة في سويسرا ضجة كبيرة في بعض أنحاء البلاد. من الناحية التربوية، كان مبرر وجود تعليم الدين الإسلامي، على غرار التعليم المسيحي الطائفي، لا جدال فيه، إذ كان الهدف هو توجيه الأطفال والشباب باللغة الألمانية في خطواتهم الأولى نحو تكوين قدرة لغوية دينية خاصة بهم. ومع ذلك، لا يوجد اليوم سوى حفنة من مشاريع تعليم الدين الإسلامي، وكلها موجودة في سويسرا الناطقة بالألمانية. في نفس الفترة، ناقشت الأوساط المتخصصة في سويسرا وفي بلدان أوروبية أخرى الشكل الأنسب للتربية الدينية للأطفال والشباب اليوم. هل التعليم الطائفي في المدرسة له معنى (لا يزال)؟ وإذا كان الأمر كذلك، فما هو دور الجماعات الدينية في هذا السياق؟ وكيف ينبغي التعامل مع الدين في المواد الدراسية الأخرى؟ تندرج النقاشات حول تعليم الدين الإسلامي الطائفي وكذلك حول التعليم “المحايد” للأديان، والذي يمكن أن يشمل أي دين، في سياق الاتجاهات الكبرى مثل العلمنة والفردنة والتعددية، وكذلك في سياق النقاشات المجتمعية، التي تكون أحيانًا عاطفية للغاية، حول المسلمات والمسلمين باعتبارهم أكبر أقلية دينية.
By the same author on Pluriel
Professionalising Muslim Spiritual Care in Plural Societies: Swiss and Bosnian Experiences
Hansjörg Schmid Published as Professionalising Muslim Spiritual Care in Plural Societies. Swiss and Bosnian Experiences (SZIG/CSIS-Studies 15, December 2025), this volume is the outcome of a…
Anti-Muslim Racism in Switzerland: A Baseline Study
Noemi Trucco · Amir Dziri · Hansjörg Schmid Commissioned by the Swiss Confederation’s Service for Combating Racism (SLR), this study (SZIG/CSIS-Studies 12, 2025) is the first comprehensive baseline survey of anti-Muslim racism…
Exploring Islamic Social Work. Between Community and the Common Good
Hansjörg Schmid This open access book addresses, for the first time, Islamic social work as an emerging concept at the interface of Islamic thought and social…
A Response to Public Discourse? Intracultural Islamic Social Work in a Plural Society
Hansjörg Schmid · Baptiste Brodard As the public discourse on Islam is strongly influenced by the issue of radicalisation, the topic of prevention is gaining in importance and legitimacy.…
Related resources: « Islam in Europe »
Scientific Evaluation of Islamic Religious Education in North Rhine-Westphalia
Mouhanad Khorchide Conducted by the Center for Islamic Theology at the University of Münster (directed by Mouhanad Khorchide) at the request of the Ministry of Education…
Public order and religious family rights. Sustainability and limits of an evolving legal relationship
Ilaria Valenzi Abstract The public-order clause, which safeguards the fundamental principles of the legal order, is today tested by the circulation of family models rooted in…
Muslim worship in France: is the State-led reorganization underway?
Mohamed-Ali Mostfa In this article published on February 26, 2025, on The Conversation, Ali Mostfa analyzes the evolution of the Forum of Islam in France (Forif),…
Islam in Europe or European Islam?
In this conference given on January 30, 2025, at PISAI (Pontifical Institute for Arabic and Islamic Studies) in Rome, political scientist Olivier Roy offers…
Salafist Movements in Europe: Between Local and Transnational Mobilizations
Mohamed-Ali Adraoui In this chapter, the author sheds light on the main sociological features and academic debates on the issue of Salafism in Europe. Through a…
Bad guy or good guy? The framing of an imam
Noemi Trucco In this paper, we investigate framing in the case of an imam in Switzerland. We conducted a qualitative content analysis of 175 articles from…