French

2006

The emergence of the Nostra Ætate Declaration at Vatican Council II

“The text of the Declaration on the Church’s Relations with Non-Christian Religions (Nostra Aetate) was undoubtedly one of the final surprises of the Second Vatican Council, because no one had thought of it during the preparation of the Council, although the Catholic world then experienced significant changes in its way of considering the great religions of the world. It is therefore necessary to get an idea of the change in mentality that had already taken place regarding the discernment that Catholics were trying to make of the religion of Muslims, especially since some of the writings did not fail to exert some influence on the Council Fathers. Such a prerequisite makes it possible to better understand how the text of the Declaration appeared before the third session of the Council, knowing several successive drafts to insert into documents that also varied. It was only after these curious adventures that the fourth session took care of assuring him of final drafting, especially as regards the relationship between Christians and Muslims. All these things explain the four divisions of the present inquiry on the subject, for the very commentary on the Declaration and the subsequent use of it by the Popes and the Dicasteries of Rome are the subject of another analysis.”

“Le texte de la Déclaration sur les relations de l’Eglise avec les religions non chrétiennes (Nostra Aetate) a sans doute été une des surprises finales du Concile Vatican II, car nul n’y avait songé lors de la préparation du Concile, bien que le monde catholique ait alors connu des évolutions significatives en sa manière de considérer les grandes religions du monde. Il convient donc de se faire une idée du changement des mentalités qui s’était déjà opéré quant au discernement que les catholiques tentaient de se faire de la religion des musulmans, d’autant plus que certains écrits ne manquèrent pas d’exercer alors quelque influence sur les Pères conciliaires. Un tel préalable permet de mieux comprendre comment le texte de la Déclaration fit son apparition avant la troisième session du Concile, connaissant plusieurs rédactions successives à insérer en des documents qui variaient également. Ce n’est qu’à la suite de ces curieuses aventures que la quatrième session s’occupa de lui assurer une rédaction définitive, surtout en ce qui concerne le rapport des chrétiens avec les musulmans. Toutes choses qui expliquent les quatre divisions de la présente enquête sur le sujet, car le commentaire même de la Déclaration et l’usage qu’en firent ensuite les Papes et les dicastères de Rome relèvent d’une autre analyse.”

Maurice Borrmans

Resources of this researcher

Resources related toMuslim-Christian Dialogue

videos

Artificial Intelligence, a New God? Christian and Muslim Perspectives

On 20 October 2026, the Centre for Interreligious Studies (ZIRS) at the University of Innsbruck, a partner institution of Pluriel, opened the semester of its online interreligious conversation seri...

Couverture du livre Le dialogue islamo-chrétien, une chance pour l'Afrique, sous la direction d'Emmanuel Pisani, préface de Mgr André Guèye, L'Harmattan, 2026

publication

Christian-Muslim Dialogue, an Opportunity for Africa

  • Emmanuel Pisani

At a time when sub-Saharan Africa is undergoing profound socio-political change and the rise of religious radicalism, Christian-Muslim dialogue emerges as an essential requirement and a condition f...

Couverture de Christliche und islamische Hermeneutiken. Grundlagen und interreligiöse Erkundungen (TVZ, 2026)

publication

Christian and Islamic Hermeneutics: Foundations and Interreligious Explorations

  • Beate Bengard

Published in October 2026 by TVZ (Theologischer Verlag Zürich) in the series “Beiträge zu einer Theologie der Religionen” (vol. 30, 451 p.), Christliche und islamische Hermeneutiken: Gr...

article

Islamic Visions of Jesus: Revelation, Prophecy, and Eschatology

  • Antonio Cuciniello

Abstract Published in the collective volume Jerusalem in Memory and Eschatology: Jewish, Christian, and Muslim Visions of the Past and Future of Jerusalem, edited by Emma O'Donnell Polyakov (Blo...

article

Questions on Islamic Soteriology in Early Islam

  • Jaume Flaquer Garcia

Abstract Published under the original title "Cuestiones sobre la soteriología islámica en el islam primitivo" in the collective volume Riesgos y fidelidades. Miradas teológicas para un mundo plu...

article

The Uncreated Muslim Qur’an and the Eternally Begotten Christian Logos

  • Jaume Flaquer Garcia

Abstract Published under the original title "El Corán musulmán increado y el Logos cristiano eternamente engendrado" in the monographic section Logos, Agape, Sarx. Una dialógica cristiana of iss...

article

The First Council of Nicaea (325) and the Christian-Muslim Dialogue on God’s Unity and Trinity

  • Dirk Ansorge

Abstract Published under the original title "Das erste Konzil von Nizäa (325) und der christlich-muslimische Dialog über Gottes Einheit und Dreifaltigkeit" in issue 2/2025 of CIBEDO-Beiträge, th...

Portrait du grand imam d'al-Azhar Ahmed al-Tayeb

article

Christian-Muslim Relations Today: Some Reflections

  • David Marshall

Abstract Published as "Christian-Muslim Relations Today: Some Reflections" in a special issue of The Muslim World marking the 50th anniversary of the Duncan Black Macdonald Center (Hartford), th...