The authoritarian republic. Islam in France and the Republican illusion
Publisher’s presentation
The logic of suspicion has become the compass of the French state.
Since 2015 and the attacks of January and November, the preventive and repressive policy of the State has been inflected, through a whole series of new legal devices and means, to the detriment of individual and collective liberties, and to the great displeasure of human rights organisations. Authoritarian practices, which can be seen here and there, have developed and spread from the centres of institutional power, with the direct or indirect support of certain associative actors, activists and, more rarely, some researchers.
The deployment of a security arsenal is neither a novelty nor an incongruity in a democracy, especially when exceptionally serious and deadly phenomena occur. On the other hand, what is certainly new is the target of the repression; today it is concentrated more than in the past on minority groups, perceived as deviant, or supposedly more deviant than others, because of their origin and presumed religion, despite the denials and the conventional speeches.
It is then that republicanism falters, its principles crumble on the altar of, among other things, a blatant instrumentalisation of secularism, transformed by some into a disciplinary tool for bodies and minds, or even a catechism without a Church. It is therefore no longer just the law that is being tightened, but the political discourse that is becoming more rigid, more martial and moralising. The state, its representatives and its relays no longer target exclusively the fomenters and perpetrators of acts of terrorism. An overbidding can now be seen in the appreciation of lifestyles and the content of religious doctrines professed and taught in particular in Muslim circles. A logic of suspicion is thus being insinuated and established, in which the media regularly participate, breaking with the ethics of responsibility. This logic of suspicion bypasses the legalism embodied by Muslim actors and social agents, who are increasingly called upon to prove their republican attachment, even though the financial and economic elites, supported or endorsed by the State, have long since seceded.
Présentation de l’éditeur
La logique du soupçon est devenue la boussole de l’État français.
Depuis 2015 et les attentats de janvier et novembre, la politique préventive et répressive de l’État s’est infléchie, par toute une série de nouveaux dispositifs et moyens légaux, au détriment des libertés individuelles et collectives, et au grand dam des organisations de défense des droits humains. Des pratiques autoritaires, repérables çà et là, se sont développées et étendues depuis les centres du pouvoir institutionnel, avec le concours direct ou indirect de certains acteurs associatifs, activistes et, plus rarement, quelques chercheurs.
Le déploiement d’un arsenal sécuritaire n’est ni une nouveauté ni une incongruité en démocratie, surtout lorsque surviennent des phénomènes exceptionnellement graves et meurtriers. En revanche, ce qui est assurément nouveau, c’est la cible de la répression ; celle-ci se concentre aujourd’hui plus qu’hier sur des groupes minoritaires, perçus comme déviants, ou supposément plus déviants que d’autres, à raison de l’origine et de la religion présumée, malgré les dénégations et les discours convenus.
C’est alors que le républicanisme vacille, ses principes s’effritent sur l’autel entre autres d’une instrumentalisation flagrante de la laïcité, transformé par certains en outil disciplinaire des corps et des esprits, voire en catéchisme sans Église. Ce n’est donc plus seulement la loi qui se durcit, mais véritablement le discours politique qui se rigidifie, se fait plus martial et moralisateur. L’État, ses représentants et ses relais ne visent plus exclusivement les fomenteurs et auteurs d’actes de terrorisme. Une surenchère se lit désormais dans l’appréciation des styles de vie et le contenu des doctrines religieuses professées et enseignées en particulier dans les milieux musulmans. S’insinue et s’installe ainsi une logique du soupçon à laquelle participent régulièrement des médias en rupture avec l’éthique de responsabilité. Cette logique de la suspicion passe outre le légalisme incarné par les acteurs et agents sociaux musulmans, sommés toujours davantage de faire la preuve de leur attachement républicain alors même que les élites financières et économiques, elles, soutenues ou adoubées par l’État, ont fait sécession depuis longtemps.
By the same author on Pluriel
God Is with Us: How Islam and Judaism Justify Violence
Haoues Seniguer Long before October 7, 2023—and even more so since—certain politicized strands of Judaism and Islam have been creating conditions that legitimize, escalate, and sacralize…
Revival and Dynamics of Islamic Studies in Europe
Michel Younès · Emmanuel Pisani · Cédric Baylocq · Zohra Aziadé Zemirli · Michele Brignone · Haoues Seniguer “In a troubled international context where Islam is sometimes defined as an ideological marker of many conflicts, academic research drawing on history, sociology, and…
Muslim Theologies of Religious Pluralism. Proceedings of the Colloquium Held on November 20 and 21, 2021
Emmanuel Pisani · Cédric Baylocq · Anne-Sophie Vivier-Muresan · Zohra Aziadé Zemirli · Charbel Attallah · Haoues Seniguer · Youssouf Sangaré The laboratory of the Institute of Science and Theology of Religions of Paris (Theologicum, ICP) presents here the outcome of four years of research…
Who is an authority in Islam in Switzerland and France?
Haoues Seniguer · Erwin Tanner · Michel Younès Elements of answers to a question studied by the research group on the theme "Authority and regulation in Islam" of the Centre for the…
Authority and Regulation in Islam – Research group in Lyon
Erwin Tanner · Haoues Seniguer · Michel Younès Presentation of the research group on "Authority and Regulation in Islam" of the Centre for Cultural and Religious Studies (CECR, UCLy) with Michel Younès,…
The (neo) Muslim Brothers and the new capitalist spirit
Haoues Seniguer -
Related resources: « Islam in Europe »
Scientific Evaluation of Islamic Religious Education in North Rhine-Westphalia
Mouhanad Khorchide Conducted by the Center for Islamic Theology at the University of Münster (directed by Mouhanad Khorchide) at the request of the Ministry of Education…
Public order and religious family rights. Sustainability and limits of an evolving legal relationship
Ilaria Valenzi Abstract The public-order clause, which safeguards the fundamental principles of the legal order, is today tested by the circulation of family models rooted in…
Muslim worship in France: is the State-led reorganization underway?
Mohamed-Ali Mostfa In this article published on February 26, 2025, on The Conversation, Ali Mostfa analyzes the evolution of the Forum of Islam in France (Forif),…
Islam in Europe or European Islam?
In this conference given on January 30, 2025, at PISAI (Pontifical Institute for Arabic and Islamic Studies) in Rome, political scientist Olivier Roy offers…
Salafist Movements in Europe: Between Local and Transnational Mobilizations
Mohamed-Ali Adraoui In this chapter, the author sheds light on the main sociological features and academic debates on the issue of Salafism in Europe. Through a…
Religious Diversity, Interreligious Perspectives, and Islamic Religious Education in Switzerland: Current Situation and Room for Maneuver
Hansjörg Schmid Twenty years ago, the first pilot projects of Islamic religious education (IRE) in public schools in Switzerland caused a stir in some parts of…